Best Psychological Thrillers on Netflix Right Now (February 2024)

Pradeep
15 Min Read

Best Psychological Thrillers on Netflix: When browsing through a streaming platform as extensive as Netflix, the vast catalog of content can be overwhelming. Even after narrowing down the genres, the abundance of options can make it difficult to choose. Avoiding the risk of starting a new movie only to realize it’s not enjoyable and then having to search for another one can be a challenge.

Best Psychological Thrillers on Netflix

To hopefully help you navigate the labyrinth of movies that is Netflix while searching for a new psychological thriller to watch, we’ve put together a list of great picks for you to watch during your next night on the couch. With any luck, you’ll find something that fits your fancy and you enjoy watching.

Disclaimer: These titles are available on US Netflix.

I Care A Lot

Rotten Tomatoes: 78% | IMDb: 6.4/10

Release Date February 19, 2021

Runtime 118 minutes

Seldom does a female antihero emerge that makes you feel conflicted about supporting her schemes. This is the case with the darkly humorous thriller, I Care A Lot, in which a deceitful woman earns her living by becoming the court-appointed guardian to vulnerable elderly individuals, persuading the courts that they are incapable of caring for themselves and seizing their wealth.

However, she finds herself in perilous territory after taking control of the guardianship of a crime lord’s mother. The game of cat and mouse keeps you on the edge of your seat until the final moments of the movie. Rosamund Pike portrays the meticulous yet manipulative con artist, unwilling to relinquish her operation without a fight; in fact, her captivating performance earned her a Golden Globe. – Meredith Loftus

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

Don’t Worry Darling

Rotten Tomatoes: 38% | IMDb: 6.3/10

Managed by enigmatic Frank (portrayed by Chris Pine), Victory, California appears to be a typical company town, but Alice (played by Florence Pugh) begins to suspect that there may be dark secrets lurking beneath its tranquil facade. Directed by Olivia Wilde, “Don’t Worry Darling” skillfully creates a sense of unease typically found in horror films without fully embracing the genre.

The movie takes its time to build tension and is elevated by the compelling performances of its talented cast, including Pugh, Gemma Chan, and Wilde herself. Throughout its intricate storyline, “Don’t Worry Darling” gradually reveals clues, challenging the audience to piece them together and uncover the mystery. – Jake Hodges

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

Missing

Rotten Tomatoes: 88% | IMDb: 7.1/1

Missing

Release Date January 20, 2023

Director Nicholas D. Johnson , Will Merrick

Runtime 111 minutes

Best Psychological Thrillers on Netflix: If you’ve ever experienced the anxiety of not hearing from someone for a little longer than expected, you’ll understand the intense worry and fear that can consume you until you make contact. Directed by Will Merrick and Nicholas D. Johnson, “Missing” effectively captures this sensation in a single film, like capturing lightning in a bottle.

The film follows the perspective of June Allen (played by Storm Reid), a teenage girl eagerly anticipating a party with her friends while her mom is away. However, when her mom doesn’t return, June takes on the search herself. Presented in a screen life format using footage from various devices expertly woven together to tell the story, the movie takes the audience on a thrilling journey where they feel like they’re in the driver’s seat the entire time. – Tauri Miller

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

The Strays

Rotten Tomatoes: 54% | IMDb: 4.8/1

The Strays

Release Date February 22, 2023

Director Nathaniel Martello-White

Cast Ashley Madekwe

Runtime 1 hr 40 min

The saying goes that the past always resurfaces, and now a woman finds herself confronted by her own history. Ashley Madekwe (known for her role in Revenge) portrays Neve, a Black woman who carefully molds her life to fit into the white suburbs by rejecting her Black identity and assimilating into the world of an upper-middle-class housewife.

However, her carefully constructed facade begins to unravel when two strangers appear, infiltrating her children’s school and shadowing her every move. Writer/director Nathaniel Martello-White creates a gripping film where nothing can be taken at face value — not even the audience’s understanding of the events unfolding on screen. This unsettling tale of a woman’s attempt to distance herself from her origins will leave viewers glancing over their shoulders long after the movie ends. – Tauri Miller

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

The Good Nurse

Rotten Tomatoes: 74% | IMDb: 6.8/1

The Good Nurse

Release Date October 26, 2022

Director Tobias Lindholm

Runtime 2 hr 1 min

Jessica Chastain, known for her role in The Eyes of Tammy Faye, plays alongside Eddie Redmayne in the gripping and suspenseful movie The Good Nurse, directed by Tobias Lindholm, who also worked on Mindhunter. The film is based on a chilling true story and follows a critical care nurse (Chastain) who begins to suspect her coworker (Redmayne) of causing deaths in their hospital.

Written by Krysty Wilson-Cairns, The Good Nurse stays rooted in real-life events, while the high stakes for these medical professionals ultimately come down to life or death. With outstanding performances from the Oscar-winning actors, The Good Nurse delivers two hours of heart-pounding tension. – Yael Tygiel

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

The Platform

Rotten Tomatoes: 80% | IMDb: 7.0/1

The Platform

Release Date March 20, 2020

Cast Ivan Massagué , Zorion Eguileor , Antonia San Juan , Emilio Buale

Runtime 94 minutes

The Platform is a distinctive and incredibly frightening thriller that provides sharp societal commentary on class similar to Squid Game. The movie follows individuals residing in a concrete tower, either as punishment for a crime or as volunteers. Everyone in the tower is provided food through a platform that starts at the top of the building and gradually descends.

Those at the top enjoy a variety of delicious dishes, while those at the bottom are left with meager portions. Every month, the residents are reorganized, leading to shifts in power dynamics. The Platform is intense and unsettling, making it a challenging yet captivating and significant viewing experience. – Taylor Gates

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

Hypnotic

Rotten Tomatoes: 24% | IMDb: 5.3/10

Hypnotic

Release Date May 11, 2023

Runtime 93 minutes

Kate Siegel, known for her roles in The Haunting of Hill House and Bly Manor as well as Hush, showcases her talent once again in the horror film Hypnotic. The story follows Jenn, a young woman determined to make positive changes in her life, including seeking help from a hypnotherapist named Jason O’Mara. As she undergoes hypnotherapy sessions, she starts to encounter dangerous consequences that could endanger both herself and those around her. While the plot may occasionally venture into predictable and absurd territory, Hypnotic offers an entertaining thrill ride that is best enjoyed with friends and a big bowl of popcorn. – Taylor Gates

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

The Devil All The Time

Rotten Tomatoes: 56% | IMDb: 7.

The Devil All The Time

Release Date September 11, 2020

Director Antonio Campos

Cast Donald Ray Pollock , Bill Skarsgard , Tom Holland , Michael Banks Repeta , Emilio Subercaseaux Campos , Emilio Subercaseaux Campos

Runtime 666

Director Antonio Campos’ The Devil All The Time paints a grim picture of life in America from 1950 to the mid-1960s, making it an incredibly best psychological horror film. The story revolves around a diverse group of characters whose lives become intertwined, based on the novel by Donald Ray Pollock, who also serves as a fitting narrator for the increasingly dark events.

At the center is Tom Holland’s character, Arvin, a young man grappling with trauma while trying to do right by his loved ones in a world filled with malevolence. Holland delivers a standout performance, holding his own against the menacing Robert Pattinson, who plays a controlling new preacher. While not a feel-good movie, it effectively showcases the strengths of its characters and fully captures the bleakness of the world they inhabit.

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

I’m Thinking of Ending Things

Rotten Tomatoes: 82% | IMDb: 6.6/10

It may be time to consider ending that romantic relationship. Adapted from Iain Reid’s 2016 novel of the same name, Charlie Kaufman’s film “I’m Thinking of Ending Things” is a captivating and bewildering psychological thriller that will leave you pondering numerous questions, theories, and concerns. A young woman, portrayed by Jessie Buckley, begins to have doubts about her budding romance with Jake, played by Jesse Plemons. Despite her hesitations, she agrees to accompany him to his parents’ remote cabin, where she soon experiences deep regret. There’s something unsettling about the family and the cabin itself. What is reality and what is merely a figment of her imagination? And what is the mysterious story behind the old janitor? – Emily Bernard

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

The Woman in the Window

Rotten Tomatoes: 25% | IMDb: 7.5/10

The Woman in the Window

Release Date May 14, 2021

Director joe wright

Runtime 101

Spying on your neighbors can lead to nothing good. The Woman in the Window, based on A.J. Finn’s 2018 novel of the same name, portrays the life of Anna Fox (played by Amy Adams), a reclusive and agoraphobic woman who lives alone in a large Manhattan brownstone, with the exception of her basement tenant David (played by Wyatt Russell). She spends her time drinking, keeping in touch with her estranged husband and daughter, and observing her neighbors.

She has a clear view into the home across the street, which was recently bought by the Russell family. One night, she witnesses what she believes to be Alistair Russell (played by Gary Oldman) killing his wife Jane (played by Julianne Moore) in the living room. Anna contacts the authorities, but struggles to convince them of what she saw. Will the woman in the window be able to find justice for her deceased neighbor?

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

Rebecca

Rotten Tomatoes: 38% | IMDb: 6.0/10

Rebecca

Release Date October 16, 2020

Runtime 121

While nothing can truly rival Hitchcock’s award-winning Psychological thrillers film Rebecca from 1940, which was based on Daphne du Maurier’s novel, the 2020 remake by Ben Wheatley, known for Kill List and High-Rise, is a visually impressive and unsettling adaptation in its own right. Often overlooked, the Netflix Original Psychological Thrillers  features Lily James as Mrs. de Winter, the new spouse of recently widowed Maxim de Winter (played by Armie Hammer), who is said to have lost his wife Rebecca in a boating accident.

Upon arriving at her new residence, Mrs. de Winter encounters an unwelcoming housekeeper named Mrs. Danvers (portrayed by Kristin Scott Thomas), who clearly favors Rebecca over Maxim’s new wife. Confronted with marriage to a man concealing a history of secrets, Mrs. de Winter seeks answers, but she may not be prepared for what she uncovers.

Certainly, no one can surpass Hitchcock, and that’s perfectly fine. However, Wheatley’s adaptation of the timeless tale is expertly crafted with outstanding performances from the lead actors, and remains a delightful viewing experience. If you haven’t seen the 1940 film, even better. You can approach the 2020 version of Rebecca with an open mind and form your own opinion on whether it’s a quality film or not, but be sure to also treat yourself to the original version.

Watch Trailer

Watch on Netflix

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ultra Romantic Netflix series with 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes “One Love”: Bob Marley Biopic Continues Global Box Office Success HanuMan Box Office Collecton: Hanuman Movie Hit Box Office Dive into the Most Thrilling Netflix Movies – Our Top Picks How to Watch NBA Basketball from Anywhere for Free